The Dual-Citizen Move
The exact tax, banking, and border checklist for dual citizens moving Canada to the US (or vice versa) — without getting hit by CRA/IRS penalties.
I moved Calgary → New York → Tampa → Miami with a one-way ticket and no plan, and I paid for every lesson in fees and friction. Then I moved back to Calgary on November 1, 2026 for a temporary six-month reset — so I've now done this move in both directions.
This is the exact tax, banking, and border checklist for dual citizens moving Canada to the US (or vice versa) — without getting hit by CRA/IRS penalties.
The information you need is scattered across CRA, the IRS, your bank, the border, and your province's health ministry, and none of them tells you the order to do it in. I put the whole thing in one place, in order, as a recipe: do X, then Y, then Z.
Every other move guide is about visas. This isn't a visa guide — the visa was never my problem. I'm a dual citizen, born in Brooklyn, raised in Calgary, and I already had the legal right to move. What I didn't have was the order of operations — and the mistakes cost real money.
If you're moving on a visa or green card, most of this still applies — I just don't cover the visa itself.
WHAT'S INSIDE (39 pages):
• TAX — the filings that fine you: the departure tax "pretend sale" and how to defer it, FBAR penalties (willful: greater of $165,353 or 50% of your balance, per account, per year), Form 8938 thresholds and $10,000–$60,000 penalties, FEIE and the Foreign Tax Credit so you don't pay twice, the Streamlined way back if you missed years, the 122-day snowbird trap, and NY vs. Florida — ~$8,302/year in state + city tax at $100k in NYC vs. $0 in Florida.
• BANKING + HEALTH — the things that lock you out: the SSN-first sequence, why your bank can freeze your account for moving (and the exact question to ask it in writing first), W-9 vs. W-8BEN (dual citizens: always W-9), credit that resets to zero in each country, and the health rules — Ontario covers only up to $50/day outpatient and $200–$400/day inpatient for US care, Alberta pays $100/day, and your Marketplace window is 60 days that does not reopen.
• BORDER + GOODS — the things that get seized: the personal exemption tables (Canada + US), settler vs. former resident (I learned I'm a former resident — $10,000 per-item cap), what not declaring costs (CBSA: seizure + 25–70% of value; CBP: forfeiture + up to the item's full value), and vehicles in depth — RIV fee CAD $325, the 25% surtaxes, the 72-hour export notice, Florida's 10-day registration clock.
• The checklist, in order — 17 items across the three pillars.
• My real costs: my 4 suitcases back to Calgary cost $495 — more than my flight. Bags 3 and 4 were $200 EACH.
• City playbooks: New York, Tampa, Miami — the honest breakdown of each.
This is my lived experience plus publicly available official information — not legal, tax, or immigration advice. Fees, forms, and deadlines change, so check the current version with the official source before you act.